There are several types of interventions for addiction, and they differ in who leads, whether the substance user knows ahead of time and how much the family itself has to change. The main types are the Johnson model, a surprise meeting built around confrontation; the invitational model, where the substance user is invited to a family meeting ahead of time; the systemic model, where the whole family is involved and the enabling around the addiction is addressed; and the CRAFT model, where the family changes how it responds at home. At Family First Intervention, every intervention addresses the whole family system, including the people closest to the addiction.
Most people are familiar with interventions based on what they’ve seen on TV or in movies. It seems simple: Confront your loved one about their addiction until they see the light and agree to treatment.
While this makes for great drama, in real life, families are looking for less drama, not more drama. Many families have tried to stage their own interventions and failed. Even when they succeed in getting their loved one to go to rehab, relapse is common.
With the support of professional interventionists using the most successful intervention models, families can take back control of the situation from the addict by learning where to correctly place responsibility and accountability.
Three Common Family Intervention Models for Addiction Recovery
There are three popular intervention models, two of which we recommend and one which we advise families not to use:
- CRAFT Model – Community Reinforcement and Family Training teaches the family to reward healthy behavior and never reward the drinking or drug use. It is the model we draw from most, as long as a trained professional is the one delivering it.
- Johnson Model – This is the earliest intervention model and the one that most people are familiar with, as it is usually the model shown in movies and television. It has some serious flaws, so we advise against using it.
- Systemic Model – This is the most widely used model of drug and alcohol intervention due to its effectiveness in addressing the family dynamics that support addiction, not just changing the addict. It’s a solid model because it changes the systems that enable addiction to continue.
Let’s look at these intervention models more closely and explore why some work better than others.
The CRAFT Model – Changing How the Family Responds
CRAFT stands for Community Reinforcement and Family Training, and it is the model we draw from most at Family First Intervention. The rule is to reward positive behavior and never reward negative behavior. People often get this backward. They read about CRAFT and come away thinking it means staying positive no matter what the substance user does. It says the opposite.
CRAFT has one weakness, and it is who delivers the message. A family cannot be the therapist and the affected family member at the same time. We have sat in living rooms where the conversation was going well until mom said one sentence, and the sound of her voice alone set her son off. Read more about the CRAFT model of intervention.
“I could put a microphone in the family’s ear and tell them exactly what to say, and it won’t be received the same way, because it’s coming from the person who’s perceived as the problem.” — Mike Loverde, MHS, CIP
Johnson Intervention Model – Confrontation and Controversy
Dr. Vernon E. Johnson, considered to be the founder of the intervention concept, introduced his controversial method of intervention in the early 1960s. Johnson correctly stated that the family does not have to wait for the addict or alcoholic to hit rock bottom before receiving help for the addiction. However, flaws in his confrontational, non-systemic approach became apparent over time.
The Johnson model puts the emphasis on aggressively confronting the addict or alcoholic, focusing only on the behaviors of the addicted individual, with little or no emphasis on repairing the family system, a system that is in part responsible for the addiction getting worse due to enabling behavior.
While the Johnson model had a high rate of success in getting drug addicts and alcoholics into treatment, it had an extremely poor rate of long-term success in achieving sobriety.
Without a systemic approach to fixing the environment that was enabling addiction, many addicts could simply leave treatment and go back to their old ways because things at home had not changed. Focusing only on the addict and not on the family system is why the Johnson Model and non-professional intervention counselors should not be used in our experience.
Anyone can talk your loved one into treatment, but it takes a strategic, professional intervention to keep your loved one in treatment and substance-free for the long run.
Systemic Intervention Model – Family and Enabling
No addict or alcoholic maintains the addiction without the help of the family. Drug addicts and alcoholics teach their families how to handle them and their addiction, and this is the engine behind the highly effective systemic model of intervention, which focuses on changing the family instead of changing the addict or alcoholic.
With a properly executed systemic model of intervention delivered to the family, even without the addict or alcoholic present, it is possible for the intervention to be effective. This is because the systemic model of intervention is not about the addict or alcoholic anymore. It is about repairing the family system, which was broken over time by the loved one’s addiction. It’s designed to foster healing for both the family and the loved one together.
Unlike the Johnson model of intervention, which requires the addict or alcoholic to be present at the intervention and to agree to treatment, a systemic model intervention can be successful regardless of the addict’s cooperation. This is because it will change the family’s behaviors so that they are no longer enabling their loved one’s addiction.
People always ask prior to the intervention: “What if our loved one doesn’t show up?” Our answer is that he or she always does. But even if they don’t, it really won’t matter.
The goal is not to change the addict or the alcoholic so the family can heal. It is to change the family system so that the addicted person will be motivated to change.
Which intervention model does Family First Intervention use?
We draw from CRAFT first. We rarely use the Johnson model, and we use the invitational model only case by case. Whatever the approach, we work with the whole family system, and the person who is using is one part of it. Behavioral family therapy works the same way: it looks at how each person in the family affects the environment that keeps the problem going, and helps each of them understand why they do what they do. That has been our approach from the start.
Has Your Family Hit Rock Bottom?
Interventions are increasingly common as a tool to obtain the willingness of an addict or alcoholic to begin treatment. However, just talking an addict or alcoholic into treatment does nothing for the loved one’s long-term sobriety. Unless the entire group surrounding and supporting the addict changes, not only during the intervention but also thereafter, the likelihood of long-term sobriety is compromised.
Our interventionists’ goal is not to force or coerce the substance user into treatment but to have your loved one accept accountability for the addiction by directing him or her and the family onto a new path.
Intervention is not about a motivational speech to temporarily convince the addict or alcoholic to change; it is about setting healthy boundaries so families and their loved ones don’t have to keep going through the endless cycle of hostility and insanity.
The addiction is not the fault of the family. However, it is almost always the family’s responsibility for allowing their loved one to take control of the family’s emotions and decisions in order to make the addiction more comfortable for the user. Family First Intervention is able to help you and your loved one come together, get well, and increase the chances of sobriety and long-term success.
Had Enough? Ready to Take Back Control of Your Family from Your Addicted Loved One?

